Ares Games
Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: Richthofen’s Progress (sort of) historically accurate scenario generator & campaign

  1. #1

    Default Richthofen’s Progress (sort of) historically accurate scenario generator & campaign

    Richthofen’s Progress is a scenario generator and campaign game for WGF which aims to set up historically accurate(ish), often asymmetric, encounters between German and Allied aircraft over the Western Front, inspired by accounts of Jasta 2, Jasta Boelcke and Jagdgeschwader 1’s experiences. The idea is to create a historically representative mix of missions where realistic asymmetric encounters happen and players can experience the ebb and flow of advantage throughout different periods of the war, and experience the gradual increase and intensity of encounters. Players get significant bonuses for achieving missions against the odds, or even just for not running away when heavily outnumbered, so encounters such as Werner Voss’ lone dogfight in a Fokker Dr1 against 6 SE5s could happen in this campaign.

    The campaign game overall has 30 missions, but players can choose to fly as many or few missions as they like for each era. The campaign can include any of 79 different aircraft types.

    Full details are attached here: Richthofen's progress v1.3.doc, and a summary is below.

    Summary
    The game is split into 7 eras, from late 1915 to late 1918, each with its own mix of aircraft and aircraft volumes. The campaign starts off in late 1915 with mainly small encounters between aircraft such as Fokker EIIIs, Vickers FB5s and BE2s. As the campaign progresses, different aircraft types become available and older types gradually retired, more missions are flown per era, and the volume of aircraft increases. Each era consists of between 2 and 6 WGF missions.

    Aircraft types, numbers and mission types are determined based on tables with weighting so the likelihood of encountering an aircraft type in an era should roughly correspond with that aircraft's actual historical usage in that era. For each mission in an era, players roll to see who will be the attacker, which is weighted accordingly to the actual strategic position of that era, and then secretly roll to see how many aircraft and what types of aircraft they have, and for the attacker, what the mission is.

    The heart of the system is the aircraft availability table, which is based on Western Front Jastas accounts of Allied aircraft actually encountered, and aircraft production volumes. Aircraft types in an era are identified as either “Staple” or “Rare” for that era. Staple types are those which have relatively high production volumes and are in their main phase of usage in that era, while Rare aircraft are aircraft which either a) have very low production volumes (eg. Morane Saulnier N, Bristol Scout, Fokker EV), or are b) only starting to be introduced in that era (eg. Sopwith Pup in late 1916), or c) have mainly been withdrawn in that era (eg. BE2 in late 1917). Staple aircraft types are about 4 times more likely to be selected, but Rare aircraft may show up.

    If players do not have minis for all aircraft which appear in a scenario, players can either substitute similar aircraft models, or, for purists, reroll until aircraft which have minis are selected. Aircraft stats are included for all 79 aircraft, based on the Unofficial Wings of War (as was) stats from 2012. Where a new Wings of Glory model has been released, use the WGF deck and values for that aircraft. The campaign uses a points system of allocating between 10 and 30 points to aircraft types, but the system will work fine using Andrea’s tournament points system instead.

    Example
    For example, in an early 1917 scenario, the Allies will be the attacker on 1 d6 roll of 1-5, reflecting the strategic situation at the battle of Arras. Allies will have 1d6 of aircraft, which are likely to be equally split between scouts and two-seaters. With average luck, the Allied aircraft will be 1 flight each of scouts and two-seaters from the Staple list, so with good luck it could be Sopwith Triplanes escorting RE8s, or DH2s and BE2s if less fortunate. There’s a chance of a Rare aircraft appearing, which could be a brand new type such as a Bristol F2B, or an old relic like a Morane Saulnier L. Germans will have 1d6 -1 aircraft, which are probably Albatrosses, but there’s a chance of something obsolete (Fokker EIV) or new (Pfalz DIII) turning up.

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	H1 1917 #2 aircraft.png 
Views:	103 
Size:	16.5 KB 
ID:	193602

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Tables #2.png 
Views:	97 
Size:	3.4 KB 
ID:	193599

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Tables #1.png 
Views:	98 
Size:	11.7 KB 
ID:	193600

    Mission Types
    Mission types are those in the A Week Over the Front (WOTF) campaign game (see http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/sho...erator-for-WGF), except that Photo Recon is replaced by an aerodrome raid scenario. Missions are Artillery Spotting, Recon, Trench Strafing, Bombing and Aerodrome Raid. Use the same mission set-up and rules as in WOTF. As in WOTF, players can secretly note late arrivals to the scenario to lure in unwary opponents, and (except for the aerodrome raid which has a different set-up) the attacker’s mission is not declared until the end of the scenario.

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Mission table.png 
Views:	100 
Size:	6.9 KB 
ID:	193603

    Points
    As many scenarios are likely to be unbalanced, scoring is weighted in favour of the outnumbered side. Players both score points for destroying enemy aircraft, but the side which has an advantage in aircraft points does not score any mission-related points. Both sides are encouraged to have a go, as their opponent gets a “Whitewash” bonus if the mission is achieved or abandoned without the other side firing a shot or getting near the mission objective.

    Worked Example:
    It is the Verdun Era (H1 1916). The Intensity Table says there are 3 missions in this Era. Either player rolls 1d6 on the Aggression Table to see who the attacker is in the first mission. It is 3, so the Entente is the attacker in this mission.

    The players then secretly roll to determine their aircraft volumes and types for the mission. The Entente player rolls 1d6 for volumes, rolling a 3. The Entente modifier on the Volume Table for the H1 1916 Era is -1, so the Entente player has 2 aircraft for this mission. The Entente player then rolls 1d6 for each aircraft on the Category Table, scoring a four and a six, meaning both aircraft are 2-seaters. The Entente player rolls 2 d6 to see if the 2-seaters are Rare or Staple types, scoring a 2 and a 5, meaning both aircraft are Staple. There are 5 possible Entente Staple 2-seater types in this era:

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	H1 1916 aircraft.png 
Views:	99 
Size:	12.6 KB 
ID:	193601

    The player allocates a number from 1-5 to each type, and will roll again on a six. The player has 3 or fewer Staple 2-seaters so the aircraft will both be the same type. Although the player hopes for a FE2b, a 1 is rolled, meaning both aircraft are BE2cs.

    Meanwhile, the German player rolls a 4 for Volume, so when modified by -2, the German also has 2 aircraft. There is no category selection as defending aircraft are always Scouts. The German rolls a 2 and a 3 for Rarity, so both Scouts are Staples. There are 3 possible Staple Scout types (Fokker DII, Fokker EIII and Halberstadt DIII), so the German allocate 1-2 to a DII, 3-4 to an EIII and 5-6 to a DIII. The German has 3 or fewer Staple Scouts so both aircraft will be the same type. The German rolls a 4, so the German has 2 Fokker EIIIs to defend with.

    The Entente player rolls for mission type, and scores a 5, which is Balloon Busting. The Entente has no Scouts, so this converts into Bombing.

    So the mission is 2xBE2c on a bombing mission against 2xFokker EIIIs. As BE2 chances are slim, they can chose just to immediately flee, in which case the German gets 10 points for a “Whitewash”, as the British didn’t even try. Alternatively, the BE2s could have a go, fire a shot or drop a bomb vaguely near the target and then successfully flee, meaning points would be zero. In the unlikely event they actually get 50% of their bombs on target and escape the BE2s would get 10 points for the successful mission.

    Points scored would be:
    Each BE2 shot down = 10VPs to Germans
    Each Fokker EIII shot down = 15VPs to Entente
    If BE2s do not fire a shot or drop a bomb vaguely near the target = 10 VPs to Germans
    If BE2s fire a shot or drop a bomb vaguely near the target = 0 VPs to either side
    If BE2s successfully bomb = 10 VPs to Entente

  2. #2

    Default

    This looks perfect for something I was considering doing outside of the Over the Trenches campaign (if I ever get caught up, that is)
    Bookmarked.

  3. #3

    Default

    For me to play I mostly likely would even roll for which planes. I don't have most on the list

  4. #4

    Default

    Are there models for all of these?

  5. #5

    Default

    Yes, there are probably Shapeways models for all of these, and it should be reasonaly easy to play full campaigns using official WOW/WGF minis (with a couple of caveats below).

    There are 79 aircraft that could possibly appear in the campaign game, but in any one campaign of 30 missions from 1915-18 with average luck you’d probably only need 20-25 different aircraft types.

    Of the 79 possible aircraft, 29 of these are designated as Rare in the campaign, so are unlikely to actually appear. Only 3 of these have official minis (Morane Saulnier N – apparently only 49 were made and Morane Saulnier Ls were much more common, Nieuport 28 and Snipes, which had reasonable numbers but not in comparison with many other Entente aircraft types at the time, so are proportionately relatively unlikely to appear).

    Of the remaining 50 aircraft designated as Staple, 29 (58%) of these have official WOW/WGF minis, and another c.10 or so are a very close match with an existing mini (such as Albatros DI, Halberstadt CLIV or Nieuport 21, which are very similar to Albatros DII, Halberstadt CLIII and Nieuport 17 respectively). The Albatros CIII being included in Series 9 is very useful for covering early war non-Roland German 2 seaters. If you played 1917-18 about 70% of Staple aircraft have official minis.

    So unless you’re a purist and prefer to always use exactly the right model, you can play the full campaign game for all periods using official minis, with 2 exceptions:

    1) There is no BE2 official mini, and no official mini with an offset gun arc. I use an RE8 mini as the model as it has a vaguely similar look, but for the offset gun arc you’d need to print off a bespoke card (see the Files pages at http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/dow...p?do=cat&id=56). You also need the XC deck from the Giants set as the BE2 was so slow. BE2 was an extremely common aircraft from 1914-17 so it’s hard to do a proper early war campaign without it, as otherwise your Fokker EIIIs will be short of easy targets. It’s an interesting challenge trying to fly a mission with 2-3 BE2s against an Eindekker or two;

    2) There is no 2 seat pusher official mini. Several key early war aircraft (FE2b, Farman F40, Vickers FB5) are 2 seat pushers, with a distinct 180 front arc. I tend to use a DH2 model (at least it’s a pusher) with a backwards 2 seater base for the arc (see below):
    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	FE2b picture.jpg 
Views:	83 
Size:	143.7 KB 
ID:	194010
    The lazy person’s FE2b. A standard 2 seater arc on backwards actually well-matches the FE2b wide front arc and limited high rear arc.

    Therefore, if you’d like to use official minis only then it’s probably best to avoid BE2s and play scenarios from the Somme era (H2 1916) onwards.

    Decks: to play the late 1915-early 1916 era you’ll probably need the XC and XD decks from the Flight of the Giants set, or from Giant minis, as the early war aircraft are so slow. Otherwise, nearly all the decks can be made up from the other as required.

    If you’re interested I can add a column to the list which shows where each aircraft has an official mini and what a recommended substitute mini would be.

    Shapeways have a very wide range of models and I expect that they would have all the Staple aircraft, and probably most of the Rare aircraft too. So if you’re a purist and like to have exactly the right model for the aircraft then you’d probably need an extensive collection from Shapeways to get the full set.
    Last edited by JBParkland; 04-15-2016 at 14:50. Reason: corrected typo

  6. #6

    Default

    Nice looking generator, I might just have to give this a go.

    Shapeways has some wonderful planes that ARES will never get to. I love my BE2cs and Gunbus!

    See "HERE" for the list.

  7. #7

    Default

    Thanks for that, Peter.
    I have it bookmarked now.


    I guess I may have to get a few Shapeways after all ...

    Although, by the time I get to this, maybe Ares will have released at least a couple I would need.



Similar Missions

  1. Replies: 1
    Last Post: 04-03-2016, 20:26
  2. Some thoughts on a Battle of Britain scenario generator
    By Malibumax in forum WGS: Campaign Discussions
    Replies: 61
    Last Post: 07-07-2015, 12:56
  3. Random scenario generator
    By BobRoberts in forum Officer's Club
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 04-04-2013, 23:53
  4. Air plane set up and scenario generator versions 1.0
    By RickMartin in forum WGS: House Rules
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 05-02-2012, 19:27
  5. Is the WOW All Red Richthofen Fokker Accurate
    By VerySlick in forum WGF: General Discussions
    Replies: 18
    Last Post: 11-03-2011, 19:41

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •