Vote Here in Mission One Scenario's AAR

[Blackronin]

All players have finished and uploaded Mission One Scenario's AAR.
Now it's time to vote.
Voting is now open and it will be closed at Midnight April, 1.

These are the indications to be followed while voting:

Voters and players have slightly different rules about voting. Voter are members of the Aerodrome that aren't engaged in the campaign. Players are. Players cannot vote in their own AAR. Voters - to their votes count - must vote in all AAR's of that week.
A player that doesn't vote on the AAR of his fellow players will receive 1 negative point per AAR not voted.
Players and Voters must be impartial and demonstrate sportsmanship when they vote. This is for fun only.
Players and Voter can vote giving from 1 to 5 points to the AARs. One point will mean that the AARs is very basic and a five means that the AAR is excellent. These are the advised parameters for voting:

+1 or +2 per photos. Good photos and enough photos to illustrate the AAR should grant the +2.
+1 for good fluff. +2 for amazing fluff
+1 for good technical AAR.
+1 if the AAR is well bound to the Squadron and Campaign overall story.

Voters and Players can make comments in the AAR's about their votes, but votes should be posted here with the following format:

Mission 1 - Patrol over St. Caronne
Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5 + 5 + 0 + 4 + 5 + 5 = 24
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 0 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 = 20
Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 4 + 4 + 4 + 0 + 4 + 4 = 20
Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 4 + 0 + 5 + 5 + 5 + 5 = 24
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 4 + 5 + 5 + 4 + 5 + 0 = 23
Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 4 + 4 + 5 + 5 + 0 + 5 = 23

The AArs are:
Flying Officer Kyte AAR:
http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?9235-AAR-Mission-1-Patrol-over-St.-Caronne-%28Entente%29

Marechallannes AAR:
http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?9298-AAR-Mission-1-Patrol-over-St.-Caronne-%28Marechallannes-Entente%29

Tikkifriend AAR:
http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?9314-AAR-1-Mission-One-Patrol-Over-St.-Caronne-RFC-52sq

Blackronin AAR:

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?9249-Mission-1-Patrol-over-St.-Caronne-%28Central-Powers%29
Nightbomber AAR:
http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?9300-AAR-Mission-1-Patrol-over-St.-Caronne.-First-Blood.

Watchdog AAR:
http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?9233-Mission-1-Patrol-over-St.-Caronne-%28Central-Powers%29

[Marechallannes]

Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5
Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 4
Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 4
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 4
Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 4

I read five amazing AARs and didn't take care for native speakers or not.

Won't distract points for picture quality, but give Rob the extra point for the best pictures/setting.

[Blackronin]

Mission 1 - Patrol over St. Caronne
Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 4
Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 4
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5
Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 4

[Flying Officer Kyte]

Votes for mission 1. Patrol over St. Caronne.

Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 4
Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 4
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5
Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 5
Blackronin AAR ( Central Powers)-5

I was amazed at the sheer professionalism of all the AAR's. It was very hard to mark and the edge given to 3 of the players was down to purely subjective matters in the end. The magic of the crumpled paper for no mans land was inspired, and greatest fluff was the eventual criterian by which I selected the best.
Thank you all for a very entertaining set of AAR's.
Rob.
professionalism

[tikkifriend]

Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) -4
Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 4 and I forgive you for killing "Curtis";)
Marechallannes (Entente) -4
Blackronin (Central Powers) -5
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 4
Like Rob says it was all down to the add on to the report, a point I will take note of for next AAR:drinks:

[Blackronin]

"And I forgive you for killing Curtis" :lol: :lol:

[Watchdog]

"And I forgive you for killing Curtis" :lol: :lol:

And it wasn't even me... :p

I have to go through the AAR's again when I get to my room tonight, before I can cast my votes.

[tikkifriend]

And it wasn't even me...
OOps n Your right Have another .5 for your AAR:D
Well you Hun look all the same when the sun is in your eyes
:fokker:

[Watchdog]

My votes for Mission 1 - Patrol over St. Caronne AAR's:

Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 4
Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 4
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5
Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 5

All five were a good read, but some of them had this undefineable little extra. Keep it up, gentlemen.:thumbsup:

[Marechallannes]

Nightbombers voting is still missing.

Then we are complete for this week.

[Blackronin]

Nightbombers voting is still missing.

Then we are complete for this week.

Voting goes on until the end of next week.
The next Mission I'll post it tomorrow (by the rules), or today if everybody is okay with that. :)

[Watchdog]

Today would be fine with me. I can't wait for the next mission. Bring 'em on! :guns:

[Flying Officer Kyte]

Bring it on.
Rob.

[Blackronin]

I will!!
Mission II is being served hot in a few minutes. :)

[Nightbomber]

Ouchhhhh! Sorry guys I missed that voting!

Here it is:
I'd prefer not to vote, for all the reports were very nice to read and I would shake a hand of everyone of you for your efforts!
Well...it's very hard to judge...
I may be wrong and it's debatable...
but after a glass of wine...

Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5
Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 4
Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 5
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 4
Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 5

Thank you all again! You are all great flyers & writers!

:deadhorse::deadhorse::deadhorse::deadhorse::deadhorse:Nightbomber.