Vote here for Mission 10 -The Prototype

[Marechallannes]

Our Squadrons successfuly tested the new prototypes. Now they're hoping the new planes will reach the front in bigger numbers, soon

Time to rate the AARs!

Voting is now open and it will be closed at Midnight September, 30th.

These are the indications to be followed while voting:

Voters and players have slightly different rules about voting. Voter are members of the Aerodrome that aren't engaged in the campaign. Players are. Players cannot vote in their own AAR. Voters - to their votes count - must vote in all AAR's of that week.
A player that doesn't vote on the AAR of his fellow players will receive 1 negative point per AAR not voted.
Players and Voters must be impartial and demonstrate sportsmanship when they vote. This is for fun only.
Players and Voter can vote giving from 1 to 5 points to the AARs. One point will mean that the AARs is very basic and a five means that the AAR is excellent. These are the advised parameters for voting:

+1 or +2 per photos. Good photos and enough photos to illustrate the AAR should grant the +2.
+1 for good fluff. +2 for amazing fluff
+1 for good technical AAR.
+1 if the AAR is well bound to the Squadron and Campaign overall story.

Voters and Players can make comments in the AAR's about their votes, but votes should be posted here with the following format:

Mission 10 - The Prototype

Flash AAR (Entente) -
Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) -
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) -
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) -
Toddwf AAR (Entente) -
Tikkifriend (Entente) -
Blackronin (Central Powers) -
Smitty_au (Central Powers) -

The AARs:

Flash AAR (Entente) -

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?11179-Flash-amp-The-Prototype-Mission-10-Over-The-Trenches-%28Entente%29

Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) -

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?11248-The-Prototype-Flying-Officer-Kyte-%28The-Bulldogs-%29

Marechallannes AAR (Entente) -

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?11227-The-Prototype-%28Marechallannes-Entente%29

Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) -

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?11226-MISSION-10-The-Prototype-%28Nightbomber-Central-Powers%29

Toddwf AAR (Entente) -

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?11583-Over-the-Trenches-toddwf-Scenario-10-The-Prototype

Tikkifriend (Entente) -

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?11353-Mission-10-The-Prototype-AAR

Blackronin (Central Powers) -

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?11283-Mission-10-The-Prototype-%28Central-Powers-Blackronin%29

Smitty_au (Central Powers) -

http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/showthread.php?11331-Mission-10-The-Prototype-%28smitty_au%29

[flash]

Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5 - Supreme fluffdom & Flak !
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 5 - Kill & getting away clean !
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5 - Just getting away !
Toddwf AAR (Entente) - 5 - Making it home & FX !
Tikkifriend (Entente) -5 - Making it home !
Blackronin (Central Powers) - 5 - Superb result in the deckchair !
Smitty_au (Central Powers) - 5 - Putting & losing a PC on the line !

[Flying Officer Kyte]

The AAR's are getting so proffesional that I took the extreme measure of starting everyone off on five and trying to knock points off rather than keep trotting out the enivatable five for all.



Flash AAR (Entente) -5 Full of the usual bull.
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 4 Not enough story line.
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) -4 A bit below par this time.
Toddwf AAR (Entente) - 5 Enthralling story line.
Tikkifriend (Entente) -5 The Devils in the detail.
Blackronin (Central Powers) -5 Sheer cheek of the pilot.
Smitty_au (Central Powers) -5 Such a gripping story line from the perspective of the doomed pilot.

Rob.

[Marechallannes]

Nice AARs:

Flash AAR (Entente) - 4 (monochrome battleground)
Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5 (+ 1 story & pictures)
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5 (+ 1 Immelman dance)
Toddwf AAR (Entente) - 4 (monochrome battleground)
Tikkifriend (Entente) - 5 (+1 for a hard dogfight)
Blackronin (Central Powers) - 5 (+ 1 nice gaming mat and accessoires)
Smitty_au (Central Powers) - 5 (+ 1 for the homemade stuff)

[Nightbomber]

The AAR's are getting so proffesional that I took the extreme measure of starting everyone off on five and trying to knock points off rather than keep trotting out the enivatable five for all.

Flash AAR (Entente) -5 Full of the usual bull.
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 4 Not enough story line.
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - A bit below par this time.
Toddwf AAR (Entente) - 5 Enthralling story line.
Tikkifriend (Entente) -5 The Devils in the detail.
Blackronin (Central Powers) -5 Sheer cheek of the pilot.
Smitty_au (Central Powers) -5 Such a gripping story line from the perspective of the doomed pilot.

Rob.


:lol::lol::lol:
Now joking:)
Maybe it's the question of my low English skills, but when I played golf (well...a computer game) "going under par" meant a previous made "birdie" or an "eagle", so I assume I presented a good show;)
Frankly speaking my pilot's performance was not good at all, so the diplomatic lack of your mark Rob gets me to think it must have been ...3...? ;)

[Nightbomber]

Flash AAR (Entente) - 5
Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 5
Toddwf AAR (Entente) - 5
Tikkifriend (Entente) - 5
Blackronin (Central Powers) - 5
Smitty_au (Central Powers) - 5

I give all of you guys the highest marks for your outstanding devotion of your pilots in action and yourself in reporting.:thumbsup:

[Flying Officer Kyte]

:eek:Sorry Andrzej.
Must have been a bit below par myself when I wrote that.
It's another of those English things, means under the weather, not up to scratch, feeling a bit seedy, out of sorts, ie. Not very well.
I have amended my marks accordingly.
:DRob.

[Nightbomber]

Superior Officer's admonishment always makes me try harder :D :salute:

[Flying Officer Kyte]

Superior Officer's admonishment always makes me try harder :D :salute:

Oh Andrzej.
You do say the nicest things.:D
Rob.

[toddwf]

Flash AAR (Entente) - 5 - a fun game of demolition derby, with a little controversy at the end... loved it!
Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5 - wonderful, very technical read! Nice clouds and flack
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 5 - very successful flight, except for the jammed guns
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5 - tough battle, with a close ending
Tikkifriend (Entente) - 5 - very long drawn-out battle. Good job surviving in spite of the numbers
Blackronin (Central Powers) - 5 - loved the story! "Like a flying matchstick..." :lol:
Smitty_au (Central Powers) - 5 - loved the character development... tough luck on drawing the explosion

Great job guys! :drinks::pint::FOK::drunk:

[tikkifriend]

Flash AAR (Entente) -5
Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) -5
Marechallannes AAR (Entente) -5
Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) -5
Toddwf AAR (Entente) -5
Blackronin (Central Powers) -5
Smitty_au (Central Powers 5


I can only re iterate what everyone else has posted. If there was a Booker prize for AAR's you would all be short listed, they are a damn sight more interesting thah the last few years winners

Congrats to you all:clap::clap::hatsoff:
Paul

[Flying Officer Kyte]

If there was a Booker prize for AAR's you would all be short listed, they are a damn sight more interesting than the last few years winners

Congrats to you all:clap::clap::hatsoff:
Paul

I'm glad that you added the rider there Paul, otherwise we would have all felt insulted.:lol::lol::lol:
Rob.