PDA

View Full Version : WGSM: FW 190 Aces on the Attack (Osprey)



Dark Horse
06-18-2012, 04:28
Submit a Book ReviewBook Title:
FW 190 Aces on the Attack Author:
John Weal ISBN:
84 8372 22 8 Category:
Reference Format:
Paperback Summary:
I found “FW 190 Aces on the Attack” (alternatively titled "Focke-Wulf FW 190 Aces of the Western Front") to be a very interesting book. The book covers the history of this famous aircraft from its introduction in the West during 1941 and initial teething troubles, the problems it caused the Spitfire Mk V during 1942 and on to its role in the attempt to stem the American day bomber fleets later in the war and the adaptions to night fighter, fighter-bomber and finally the TA 152 version by war’s end.

There are a lot of B&W photos of various marks, 32 colour side views of aircraft including FW 190 A-2 to A-8 and Ta 152H-1. There are also 3 pictures of flight uniforms so that you can paint your tiny pilots just right.

I was quite fascinated by the lengths the British were prepared to go to, to obtain an FW 190 when they finally became fully aware of this New Kid on the Block. From a straightforward (if there was such a thing) commando raid on an airfield escorting a pilot to capture a plane, to the bizarre idea of flying a captured, badly damaged Bf 109 to a German airfield, the German-speaking British pilot (in German uniform of course) then demanding that the airfield authorities lend him an FW 190 so that he could supposedly return to the air combat that he had just been apparently shot out of. He would then of course return straight to England with it.

No, you're right, I don’t think it would have worked either. It sounds like a plot-line straight out of "Hogan’s Heroes" (where of course it would have worked spectacularly…)or "Dad's Army" (where it would not have got off Captain Mainwaring's pin-up board.

The truth of how the British actually got their FW 190 is of course at least equally bizarre and involved a VERY lost and more than a little confused (not to mention embarrassed) German aviator doing a victory roll over a British airfield and then landing on it…

Overall I enjoyed reading this book and it provided me some ideas for interesting scenarios: FW 190’s vs Swordfish anyone?

GilmoreDK
06-18-2012, 05:36
Overall I enjoyed reading this book and it provided me some ideas for interesting scenarios: FW 190’s vs Swordfish anyone? [/I][/INDENT]

Would´t that be the worlds shortest scenario? :) .. A bit like, say Fokker D.VIIF´s versus Vickers gunbuses?

Carl_Brisgamer
06-18-2012, 06:02
Would´t that be the worlds shortest scenario? :) .. A bit like, say Fokker D.VIIF´s versus Vickers gunbuses?

Not quite, for the Fairey Swordfish flew so slowly that the Fw190 pilots kept overshooting their targets and had to LOWER their landing gear to engage the biplanes!

GilmoreDK
06-18-2012, 06:40
Not quite, for the Fairey Swordfish flew so slowly that the Fw190 pilots kept overshooting their targets and had to LOWER their landing gear to engage the biplanes!

Heh.. Ok! A very long, but one sided scenario?.. I guess the defensive Lewis guns had little effect on the 190s? Hard to hit let alone seriously damage an incoming fighter with a single 30.cal.. What happened IRL? The FW190 using up their fuel and going home?

- Svend

AlgyLacey
06-18-2012, 08:18
What happened IRL? The FW190 using up their fuel and going home?

- Svend

6 swordfish at the bottom of the channel. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Donnerkeil

All but 5 of the 18 crew were killed

GilmoreDK
06-18-2012, 10:41
Very interesting story.. The escorting Spits did not succeed, but they make for a more even mission. I have Swordfish, Spits and FW-190s in 1/700th scale. I consider a mission in the "Bag the hun!" rules...

Carl_Brisgamer
06-18-2012, 16:00
I have been thinking about writing a few scenarios for an Operation Cerberus mini campaign. The Luftwaffe ace Adolph Galland organised the fighter cover for the 'Channel Dash' by Scharnhorst, Gneisenau and Prinz Eugen, and he did a very thorough job.

Wiki has the usual brief overview: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Channel_Dash

This website has a complete ORBAT: http://navweaps.com/index_oob/OOB_WWII_Atlantic/OOB_WWII_Cerberus.htm

General Galland devotes an entire chapter of his autobiography 'The First and the Last' to Operation Cerberus, available as an e-book from Scribd.com.

Dark Horse
06-19-2012, 03:08
Yes 11th February 1942: 6 torpedo swordfish & 10 spitfire V against 16 Fw 190. The Swordfish are after the 3 German capital ships in the Channel. All 6 Swordfish lost, no torpedo hits on the ships despite several launches, 3 Fw 190 shot down too. The Fw 190's had a lot of problems slowing down enough to get a serious bead on the Swordfish. Five squadrons of Spitfire V were meant to turn up but just one squadron did (# 72). One Posthumous Victoria Cross for the Swordfish flight commander: Lt Cdr Eugene Esmonde.

There are several possible scenarios there I think, or some of the following could be combined. You might be able to think of some more possibilities (except maybe not Daleks...)

1. British side wins if they achieve even one serious torpedo strike that slows/stops/sinks a ship. Escalating points win from there.
2. Even the odds with more of the allocated Spitfires turning up on time...
3. Vary the time of day; before the Fw 190s, escort was provided by 109's. At dawn & dusk, escort was 30 Bf 110's.
4. Planes from the the fighter school near Paris were also involved - I'm not sure what they flew, but whatever it was, some penalties could be imposed on their assumed lesser abilities.