Ares Games
Results 1 to 8 of 8

Thread: Vote Here in Mission Four Scenario's AAR - The Best Part of Valour

  1. #1

    Lightbulb Vote Here in Mission Four Scenario's AAR - The Best Part of Valour

    All players have finished and uploaded Mission Four Scenario's AAR - The Best Part of Valour.
    Now it's time to vote.
    Voting is now open and it will be closed at Midnight April, 29. (It's a Sunday!)

    These are the indications to be followed while voting:

    Voters and players have slightly different rules about voting. Voter are members of the Aerodrome that aren't engaged in the campaign. Players are. Players cannot vote in their own AAR. Voters - to their votes count - must vote in all AAR's of that week.
    A player that doesn't vote on the AAR of his fellow players will receive 1 negative point per AAR not voted.
    Players and Voters must be impartial and demonstrate sportsmanship when they vote. This is for fun only.
    Players and Voter can vote giving from 1 to 5 points to the AARs. One point will mean that the AARs is very basic and a five means that the AAR is excellent. These are the advised parameters for voting:

    +1 or +2 per photos. Good photos and enough photos to illustrate the AAR should grant the +2.
    +1 for good fluff. +2 for amazing fluff
    +1 for good technical AAR.
    +1 if the AAR is well bound to the Squadron and Campaign overall story.

    Voters and Players can make comments in the AAR's about their votes, but votes should be posted here with the following format:

    Mission 4 - The Best Part of Valour
    Flash AAR (Entente) -
    Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) -
    Marechallannes AAR (Entente) -
    Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) -
    Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) -
    Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) -
    Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) -

    The AArs are:
    Flash AAR:
    http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/sho...Part-of-Valour

    Flying Officer Kyte AAR:
    http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/sho...part-of-Valour

    Marechallannes AAR:
    http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/sho...nes-Entente%29

    Tikkifriend AAR:
    http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/sho...part-of-valour

    Blackronin AAR:
    http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/sho...tral-Powers%29

    Nightbomber AAR:
    http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/sho...tral-Powers%29

    Watchdog AAR:
    http://www.wingsofwar.org/forums/sho...tral-Powers%29

  2. #2

    Default

    Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 4
    Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 4
    Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 5
    Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 4
    Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 4
    Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 3

  3. #3

    Default

    Mission 4 - The Best Part of Valour

    Flash AAR (Entente) - 5
    Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 4*
    Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 5
    Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 5
    Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5
    Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 4**

    Ok, you did well again comrades, so here are the extra points:

    Flash - for a good story-picture connection.
    Tikkifriend - for his thrilling fight vs. equal enemy planes
    Blackronin - for a good story - picture connection, too
    Nightbomber - most dynamic photos

    Thought I have to explain my decision this time, because you all did much better, than I did in this mission:

    * Rob +1 for a heroic fight with an outgunned older plane / -1 because it doesn't hardly fit to the mission parameters
    ** Jan +1 for an outstanding Eagles success / -1 for missing explosions

  4. #4

    Default

    Flash AAR (Entente) -5
    Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5
    Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 5
    Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) -4
    Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5
    Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 5

    Sorrry Quim but those movement cards really do add something to the AAR so only a 4.

  5. #5

    Default

    My votes were very predictable this time. In very different ways all were excellent.
    Rob.


    Mission 4 - The Best Part of Valour
    Flash AAR (Entente) - 5
    Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 5
    Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 5
    Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 5
    Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5
    Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 5

  6. #6

    Default

    Mission 4 - The Best Part of Valour
    Flash AAR (Entente) - 5
    Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 5
    Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 5
    Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 5
    Flying Officer Kyte (Entente) - 5
    Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 4*

    All of them were excellent, but the one -1 was Jan's report this time, only for not using the explosion card, for it makes the story a bit unrealistic. Due to any other requirements it was far better AAR than an average one, like mine for example. But this is because for my individual approach only and you may have a completely different one. It's because the story of pilots I try to develop is realistic "to the bones". I love the hazardous thrill of fighting, even if my pilots die eventually. No matter. If they survive - cheers! On the other hand, I respect Jan's approach to the story. And frankly - the most important goal of the Campaign we run is not the final AAR stage. If my pilots survive - I'll be more than happy.

  7. #7

    Default

    Mission 4 - The Best Part of Valour
    Flash AAR (Entente) - 5 (Excellent report all around.)
    Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5 (Very engaging and with a very nice touch.)
    Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 5 (The B&W photos were a superb touch.)
    Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 5 (Excellent report all around.)
    Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5 (Very engaging report and nice to follow.)
    Watchdog AAR (Central Powers) - 5 (Very compelling storytelling. As it was a very extensive Mission I understand the focus in one type of photos, but that was a weakness. But I still think it deserves a 5.)
    Last edited by Blackronin; 04-23-2012 at 11:02.

  8. #8

    Default

    I liked all of them very much, very enjoyable reading and some great photos there. Well done, lads.

    Flash AAR (Entente) - 5
    Marechallannes AAR (Entente) - 5
    Tikkifriend AAR (Entente) - 5
    Blackronin AAR (Central Powers) - 5
    Nightbomber AAR (Central Powers) - 5
    Flying Officer Kyte AAR (Entente) - 5



Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •