Originally Posted by
Carl_Brisgamer
These are a great set of miniatures.
Regarding the damage points set for each aircraft I am in agreement with three of the four:
18 is right for the stop-gap Spitfire Mk.IX - basically a slightly modified 1941 Mk.V airframe fitted with a more powerful Merlin 61 engine;
The Ki-84 - a 1943 design equipped with armour protection but no self sealing tanks is deserving of an 18;
The P-51D is a 1943 design with armour and self sealing tanks, 19 is right;
However at 18 I believe the Fw 190D is somewhat understrength. Designed by Kurt Tank the airframes of all Fw 190 variants had immensely strong internal structures along with electrical control circuits less prone to battle damage than mechanical linkages - fly by wire in 1942 if you will. Even with the inline Jumo engine as opposed to the radial BMW of the Fw 190A, I would still give the 'Dora' at least a damage point value of 20. Giving the Fw 190D the same damage value as the Bf 109E-4 which was 2,000lbs lighter and much less able to absorb battle damage creates an anomaly not easily explained.
Any other perspectives on this issue?
Bookmarks